Civic Fusion: Mediating Polarized Public Disputes

Learn how people with clashing interests and values can bond to resolve controversial policy conflicts.

Negotiating Amidst Polarization

This book offers proven strategies for moving polarized parties to consensus solutions based on the author’s 25 years of mediation experience, including working with pro-life and pro-choice leaders to change the rhetoric of the abortion debate; with citizens of a failed city to reclaim their democracy; and with government, the crane industry, and unions to develop consensus federal regulations to protect workers.

Overview

Amidst political polarization, public policy mediators help disputing parties contribute their wisdom and experiences to resolve their complex public conflicts. Mediators trigger and sustain civic fusion, a phenomenon in which people with passionately different political positions bond to address common public goals without sacrificing their core values.

In Civic Fusion: Mediating Polarized Public Disputes, I draw on three of my past projects to explain how to move parties from polarization to deliberative negotiations that result in innovative consensus solutions.

  • During secret meetings in the wake of fatal attacks at two women’s health clinics in Massachusetts, as pro-life and pro-choice leaders continued to vehemently disagree about when life begins and a woman’s right to choose to terminate her pregnancy, they also acted in concert to protect born people from violence.

  • When crane accidents accounted for the highest incidence of worker fatalities and serious injuries in construction, the crane industry, unions, and the federal government engaged in regulatory negotiations that resulted in consensus standards to protect workers. As a result, fewer people will fall from or be crushed by cranes in the U.S.

  • After being pulled back from the brink of bankruptcy, the City of Chelsea reclaimed its democracy after citizen-representatives negotiated the terms of a new city charter with systematic input from thousands of fellow citizens. Ten years later, the city balances its budgets and attracts private investment.

Civic Fusion analyzes how policy mediators carefully design and implement processes to guide representative negotiators to resolve deep disagreements when the status quo is unsustainable, no party can effectively act unilaterally, and all are frustratingly stuck in place.

The story of Civic Fusion

About the author

Susan L. Podziba has been a Public Policy Mediator for twenty-five years. Her clients have included the U.S. Departments of Commerce, Defense, Education, Energy, Health and Human Services, Housing and Urban Development, Interior, Labor, and Transportation, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and U.S. Institute of Peace.

She is listed on the United Nations Mediation Roster and has provided mediation training for the U.N. Department of Political Affairs. Ms. Podziba served as Fulbright Senior Specialist in Peace and Conflict Resolution at the Amsterdam Center for Conflict Studies at the University of Amsterdam, Netherlands, and has taught graduate seminars at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School. She currently lectures and consults internationally.


Table of contents

Introduction

PART I: Civic Fusion Described and Defined

  • Chapter 1: Civic Fusion Described

  • Chapter 2: The Energies That Bind

PART II: Introduction to the Project Narratives

  • Chapter 3: The Chelsea Charter Consensus Process

  • Chapter 4: Construction Cranes Negotiated Rulemaking

  • Chapter 5: The Abortion Talks

PART III: Building the Foundation for Civic Fusion

  • Chapter 6: Conducting the Mediator’s Assessment

  • Chapter 7: Designing the Process

PART IV: Initiating and Sustaining Civic Fusion

  • Chapter 8: Facing Polarization

  • Chapter 9: Keeping the Substance in Motion

  • Chapter 10: From Certainty through Not Knowing to Curiosity

  • Chapter 11: Fostering Deliberative Negotiations

  • Chapter 12: The March to Closure

  • ‍Chapter 13: Owning the Future

Conclusion

  • Appendix A: “Talking with the Enemy,” The Boston Globe

  • Appendix B: Federal Register Notices

  • Appendix C: Ground Rules

  • Appendix D: Assessment Reports

BUY THE BOOK

BUY THE BOOK

BUY THE BOOK

BUY THE BOOK

Lectures

Recent and Upcoming


Civic Fusion: Bonding Across Deep Differences

Centre for Spirituality and Wisdom Practices

Renison University College, University of Waterloo

Waterloo, Ontario

TBD

Special Workshop: Mediation Tools and Process Design

Conflict Resolution and Mediation Program

International Graduate School for Social Sciences

Tel Aviv University

Tel Aviv, Israel

January 2023

Civic Fusion as a Leadership Tool

Hot Topics in Leadership and Negotiation

Bay Path University

Longmeadow, MA

September 2022

Past


Civic Fusion and the Hidden Connective Energies of Conflict 

PON Live!, Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School

Cambridge, MA

Video

Civic Fusion: Bonding Across Deep Differences

PATHWAYS Institute for Negotiation Education

Israel

Sacred Lands Mediation

Island Conversations

KWXX

Hilo, Hawaii

Listen